Olive Wilhelmina Powell was a suspect in the murder investigation of comic book artist Marcus Butler in Color Me Murdered (Case #22 of The Conspiracy) and a quasi-suspect in Lights Out (Case #50 of The Conspiracy).


Olive is the 16-year-old daughter of Judge Powell. She has light red hair in a ponytail and brown eyes. She wears a black shirt with a gold outlined confused face and "NEVERMIND" written in gold letters as well a multicolored charm necklace, and three silver piercings, one on her left ear and two on her right ear. It is known that Olive went to GrimCon and drinks Incredible Bulk cocktails.

In her quasi-suspect appearance, she does not wear her charm necklace.

Height 5'3"
Age 16
Weight 128 lbs
Eyes brown
Blood A-

Events of Criminal Case

Color Me Murdered

Olive became a suspect after Jones and the player learned that she was a fan of the victim. Initially thinking that the two were there to see her mother, she was informed about Marcus' death. This led her to burst into tears as she wondered who would write Miracle Girl comics after Marcus' death.

Olive was spoken to again about the insulting text messages that she sent to the victim. She revealed that Marcus was going to kill off Miracle Girl, who was the only superhero that spoke to her soul. The revelation infuriated her, leading her to send the victim the insulting texts. Olive's involvement in the case later prompted Judge Powell to arrive at the precinct and cause a scene.

Olive was found to be innocent after the team incarcerated Haruki Kato for Marcus' murder. But she later caused Gloria and the player panic when she disappeared with Carter Hayes, Gloria's son. The two were later found at the victim's comic studio, where Gloria grounded Carter and told Olive that she would inform her mother about their disappearances.

Lights Out

After arresting Ryan Min's killer, Olive came to the station, telling Rita and the player that her mother, Judge Powell, had gone missing. She then explained that her mother had not come home from Felix's trial and that she was never late, leading her to worry. She also told the team that her mother usually took a shortcut through Hutshing Square while walking to and from work, prompting them to investigate the square.

The team then found Judge Powell, who had been kidnapped by the sons of a man she had sentenced to prison. After Rita and the player arrested her kidnappers, Judge Powell was taken back to the station, where she reunited with Olive.


  • Olive is one of the characters to physically appear in two districts in The Conspiracy.
  • When meeting Judge Powell again after she was kidnapped, Olive draws her back to hug Judge Powell, making her one of the few characters to do such at one point in a cutscene.
  • Olive wears a Nevermind t-shirt, a promotional item from the album of American rock band Nirvana.

Case appearances



Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.