Minnie Starr was the killer of telegrapher Jane Pembroke in Inglorious Justice (Case #58 of Mysteries of the Past).


Minnie is a 26-year-old friend of the victim. She has curly blonde hair in a high ponytail. She dons a blue dress with navy blue sleeves. She also wears silver earrings and a silver necklace with a blue pendant and lipstick. It is known that Minnie drinks champagne, has high blood pressure and knows Lawson's speeches.

Height 6'0"
Age 26
Weight 182 lbs
Eyes blue
Blood B-

Events of Criminal Case

Minnie became a suspect after the player and Isaac identified her from a picture of her with the victim. She was surprised to hear of Jane's murder, saying they were like sisters, and had even gone to the Justice Day party together. But they had ended up getting separated, not expecting anything bad to happen at the party, but Minnie claimed that she regretted taking her eyes off Jane.

Minnie was spoken to again about a recording of her bad-mouthing the victim behind her back. Though she was not proud of it, she said that Jane got promoted to lead telegraph girl, which shocked her that she was picked out of all the workers. It had shocked her since the victim looked plain, which was why Minnie liked her, but was also the reason she felt her anger was justified despite being her friend.

It was later revealed that Minnie was the one behind Jane's murder. Upon admitting to the murder, Minnie said that it was unfair that Jane had gotten a promotion in the telegraph office and had gotten a rich husband while she had not because she was "better than her." In order to "fix the personal injustice in her life", Minnie strangled Jane with her own scarf. Judge Umbright sentenced her to life in prison.


Case appearances



  1. 1.0 1.1 Referring to the Mysteries of the Past era.


Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.