Carmen Garcia was a suspect in the murder investigation of art instructor Paul Etter in Gut Out (Case #7 of Supernatural Investigations).


Carmen is a 47-year-old waitress at Tacos Pueblo. She has brown eyes, mid-length, wavy brown hair and slight wrinkles. She wears a white dress with Rio Grande stripes and a red apron tied at her waist. Additionally, she sports a nametag pinned to her left lapel and a pearl and turquoise necklace. Moreover, she is seen holding a plate of tacos in her left hand. It is known that Carmen speaks Spanish.

Height 5'3"
Age 47
Weight 188 lbs
Eyes brown
Blood O+

Events of Criminal Case

Carmen became a suspect after Luke and the player found a menu with her note to the victim on it. She told the team that she came to Tacos Pueblo for lunch every day, and was shocked when she heard about his murder. When she mentioned that she herded goats, Luke asked her if she had encountered any animal attacks. She told them that she had been very lucky and excused herself to get back to her job.

Carmen was spoken to again about the victim's abstract portrait of her. She told the team that she found the painting ugly and wanted it destroyed when Paul presented it to her. She thought that Paul was her friend, so she was angered when he depicted her as what she viewed to be a monster.

Carmen was found to be innocent after the team incarcerated Susan Etter for Paul's murder.

Case appearances


Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.