Avery Mitchell was a suspect in the murder investigations of four people in Supernatural Investigations.


Avery is a 15-year old witch with brown eyes, freckles and curly black hair swept to her right shoulder. She wears a black hoodie covered in white and gray polka dots over a sky blue top emblazoned with multiple "HATE" words in blue letters and different sizes. In addition, she sports a pair of crescent-shaped earrings, pink blush and matching lipstick.

In her first appearance, it is known that Avery is strong, eats government cheese and listens to Kismet the Rapper.

In her second appearance, it is discovered that she has a pet owl.

In her third appearance, it is revealed that she owns a black cat named Mr Whiskers and has watched The Crucible.

In her fourth appearance, it is noted that she eats pickled human remains, has read Dealing with Demons, knows the Supernatural Defense Pledge and uses magic ink.

Height 5'3"
Age 15
Weight 99 lbs
Eyes brown
Blood A-

Events of Criminal Case

Don't Die over Spilled Milk

Avery became a suspect after Felix and the player found her schoolbook in the victim's apartment. She claimed that Todd was her tutor and revealed that she wanted to be a journalist when she grew up. She also mentioned how he used to tell her that urban legends like The Milkman were a means to oppress a disenfranchised population. She then told the team that she knew that they were not social workers or police officers and told them to talk to her again when she was with her parents.

Avery was spoken to again about her attempt to summon The Milkman in the victim's apartment. She admitted to being a good witch and claimed that she was trying to protect Bellevue Towers from The Milkman. She then told the team that the victim had inspired her to make a difference in the world and that she would have never hurt him.

Avery was found to be innocent after the team incarcerated Lyla Heller for Todd's murder. Later, Felix and the player found a pair of earrings whilst on witch Agnes Leek's quest. Per Priya, the earrings belonged to Agnes. Felix and the player returned them to her, who explained that they had been given to her by her late mother, who was also a witch. She thanked the team and told them that they had earned good magic karma.

Scry for Help

Avery became a suspect again after Chief Arrow and the player found her earring at the crime scene. She told the team that she was in Indiana to join the Walpurgis Night celebrations, although the other witches had refused to let her participate as she was underage, resulting in Belinda throwing her out. Chief Arrow then told her about the murder, surprising Avery. She then reluctantly agreed to let Felix look after her for the duration of the case.

Mid-investigation, Hope told the team that she had found Felix unconscious in his trailer and that Avery had gone missing. Felix revealed that Avery had knocked him unconscious with a spell, desperate to go to Walpurgis Night.

Avery was spoken to again after she spoke with Felix and the player through Belinda's crystal ball and told them that she had been trapped with the other kids. After apologizing for hexing Felix, she informed the team that she had been attacked with black magic after sneaking back into the castle and had been held prisoner with the missing kids. After the missing children told the team that the witches were going to eat them, the connection through the crystal ball was lost, prompting Felix to instruct the player to resume their investigation with Chief Arrow.

Avery was found to be innocent after the team incarcerated Heather Night for Belinda's murder. Later, Felix and the player found Avery and the missing children behind a trap door in the candy room. Felix informed Avery that coven leader Morgana Blackhawk had been behind the kidnappings. After Felix used the children's positive energy to render Morgana powerless, Avery accompanied the team as they interrogated Morgana. After she revealed her plans, Morgana attempted to erase the team's memory, but Avery informed her that Felix had stripped her of her powers.

After Felix and the player took Avery for a burger, FBI Agent George Mathison told the team that Chief Arrow had contacted him about them locating the kidnapped kids. After Avery and the player helped George find his car keys, they accompanied him to tell the kids that they were going home. Before she left, Avery thanked the player for never stopping looking out for her.

Hocus Pocus

Avery became a suspect for the third time after Gwen and the player saved her from an encounter with supernatural hunter Dolores Harper. She told the team that she had heard about a witch being killed at the Hocus Pocus Museum and asked if Dolores was responsible. Gwen revealed that their investigation was ongoing and that the victim was Agnes. Avery was shocked, revealing that Agnes had taught her and the other new witches so much. She mentioned that Agnes had persuaded her to visit the museum to learn about the history of witches. However, all that she had learned was that witches were poorly treated.

Avery was spoken to again about the curse she had put on Agnes. She revealed that Agnes had made fun of her, saying that she was "too nice" and that she did not have it in her to be a real witch. In an attempt to prove her wrong, she cursed her, giving her insomnia for two weeks.

Avery was found to be innocent for the third time after the team incarcerated Joseph Hardcastle for Agnes' murder.

Divided We Fall

Avery became a suspect once again after Gwen and the player found her backpack at the crime scene. After being told about the murder, Avery told the team that it had undermined the spirit of the meeting and hoped that the murder would not shake anyone's confidence. She then cited her late mentor and said that they could not allow murder to scare them, before excusing herself to prepare for the meeting.

Avery was spoken to again about her anti-vampire protest sign. She claimed that she had only made the sign to get back at Roxanne as she had never acknowledged her efforts, telling her that Avery was only at the meeting to make it look like the supernatural youth had a voice. Avery told the team that Roxanne's opinion did not surprise her and that she had fresh ideas to bring to the meeting.

Avery was found to be innocent for the fourth time after the team incarcerated Fabien de la Mort for Roxanne's murder. Later, Priya and the player (per ghost Ronnie Hawk) found a sack of strange objects in the assembly hall. Felix determined that the objects were protective talismans for each type of supernatural creature made by Avery. Priya and the player thanked Avery for the talismans, who told the team that she had felt that it was hey duty as a spellcaster to aid her fellow supernatural beings. Avery then mentioned that someone had seen missing demon rebel Arthur Darkwood outside of the stronghold, prompting Priya and the player to go looking for him while Avery distributed the talismans.


  • Avery is one of the non-main characters to physically appear in three different regions in Supernatural Investigations.
  • Avery is one of the characters to appear as a suspect four times.

Case appearances


Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.