Talk:That Sinking Feeling/@comment-64.231.3.196-20170203064239/@comment-27859838-20170203165947

Well I also believe Archie is Mr Alastor. His and Giulietta's age are close, and he also fits the hand on the Additional Investigation picture. And the motive is pretty simple: He was in love with Giulietta and wanted to hurt everyone who hurt her.