Talk:Amy Young/@comment-50.179.230.249-20150403181412

My own reason for disliking her is because I can't stand her personality and how she was given far too much tragedy in her own district. In Inner City, Hannah was able to overcome her delinquent past as a member of Inner Chaos. Yann managed to exorcise his own personal demons in Jazz Town by playing a part in finding The Puppeteer's identity. Russell made amends with his estranged father and helped stopped the cult-like Utopians in Ivywood Hills. Even Chief Marquez was able to have peace of mind in Rhine Canyon when she learned the truth about what really happened there.

No, Amy doesn't get this sort of development in White Peaks. She apparently had the most idyllic childhood so we're expecting her to have happy memories. That gets completely cancelled when the last three cases hit a little too close to home. Her overbearing mother becomes a suspect twice, her best friend gets killed, her high school sweetheart who still cares about her ends up being guilty of murder, and her idolized brother turns out to be a serial killer in the most predictable way possible. It's all to build her up into a tougher officer but it's executed so poorly that her return makes her seem rude and demanding.