Board Thread:Game Discussion/@comment-16828707-20170421090457/@comment-32726596-20170425041049

There's a possible motives/reasons to be the Scarlet Slayer :

If U pick The brothel owner, his prostitutes are start to turn down for him due to insufficient funds, thus kill them in a process.

If U pick The distillery swindler, she must kill those prostitutes to blame those Italian mobsters as prostitute murderers as well as to provoke a gang war.

If U pick The doctor, despite of those prostitutes had a mild-liking of him, he refuses their acceptance about marriage, thus kill them to reclaim Madeline as his new wife.