User blog comment:Icy34567/CASE 52 INFO/@comment-92.36.144.178-20140103072418/@comment-24197780-20140104054025

Or to simple out Max's reasoning, the first crime scene is this one, where they find Pip Huckabee's skeleton and a faded scroll. They powdered the scroll only to find a riddle which lead them to the lighthouse (2nd crime scene) and that's where they find Stuart's dead body.